We identified a bug where RELOAD fails to update the pools.
To reproduce you need to start at some config state, modify that state a bit, reload, revert the configs back to the original state, and reload. The last reload will fail to update the pool because PgCat "thinks" the pool state didn't change.
This is because we use a HashSet to keep track of config hashes but we never remove values from it.
Say we start with State A, we modify pool configs to State B and reload. Now the POOL_HASHES struct has State A and State B. Attempting to go back to State A will encounter a hashset hit which is interpreted by PgCat as "Configs are the same, no need to reload pools"
We fix this by attaching a config_hash value to ConnectionPool object and we calculate that value when we create the pool. This eliminates the need for a global variable. One shortcoming here is that changing any config under one user in the pool will trigger a reload for the entire pool (which is fine I think)
Connection to the CI databases is viewed by Postgres as coming from localhost. The pg_hba.conf file generated by the docker image uses trust for these connections, that's why we had no test coverage on SASL and md5 branches.
This PR fixes this issue. There was also an issue with under-reporting code coverage. This should be fixed now
We have encountered a case where PgCat pools were stuck following a database incident. Our best understanding at this point is that the PgCat -> Postgres connections died silently and because Tokio defaults to disabling keepalives, connections in the pool were marked as busy forever. Only when we deployed PgCat did we see recovery.
This PR introduces tcp_keepalives to PgCat. This sets the defaults to be
keepalives_idle: 5 # seconds
keepalives_interval: 5 # seconds
keepalives_count: 5 # a count
These settings can detect the death of an idle connection within 30 seconds of its death. Please note that the connection can remain idle forever (from an application perspective) as long as the keepalive packets are flowing so disconnection will only occur if the other end is not acknowledging keepalive packets (keepalive packet acks are handled by the OS, the application does not need to do anything). I plan to add tcp_user_timeout in a follow-up PR.
Least outstanding connections load balancing can improve the load distribution between instances but for Pgcat it may also improve handling slow replicas that don't go completely down. With LoC, traffic will quickly move away from the slow replica without waiting for the replica to be banned.
If all replicas slow down equally (due to a bad query that is hitting all replicas), the algorithm will degenerate to Random Load Balancing (which is what we had in Pgcat until today).
This may also allow Pgcat to accommodate pools with differently-sized replicas.
